Mechanical, magnetic, or optical: which keyboard switch should you choose?

A keyboard might be just another input device for many, but a highly personal and valued part of their PC setup for others. While many parts come together to determine how good a keyboard sounds and feels, the switch is perhaps one of the most important. Users typically have three kinds of keyboards to choose from, depending on the switch type: mechanical, magnetic (Hall effect), and optical.

The type of switch you choose decides not only the bulk of your typing experience, but also the kind of performance and features you can expect from your keyboard. Mechanical switches might be the most common, but optical and magnetic switches also have their place on the market, offering unique advantages to gamers and professionals alike.

Mechanical vs. magnetic vs. optical switches: how do they work?

It’s all in the name

Let’s start by breaking down the physical differences between mechanical, magnetic, and optical switches. As the name suggests, a mechanical switch relies on physical contact between its internal components to register a keypress. When you press a key on a mechanical keyboard, the switch stem compresses the spring inside and makes contact with the metal leaves underneath, completing the circuit and actuating the respective key. On releasing the key, the switch returns to its original position, ready for actuation again.

Magnetic or Hall effect switches operate differently, utilizing the Hall effect phenomenon discovered in 1879 by Edwin Hall. Instead of completing an electrical circuit, Hall effect switches rely on changes in magnetic fields to register a keypress. Each magnetic switch has a magnet inside it, which, when the key is pressed, triggers a change in the Hall effect sensor present either in the lower part of the switch or on the PCB.

This action registers the respective key, detecting the varying strength in the magnetic field inside the switch. The recent explosion in the number of Hall effect keyboards on the market has been driven, in part, by the popularity of excellent models from brands like Wooting, Razer, and SteelSeries.

Optical switches are similar to mechanical switches in the sense that they have mechanical components inside them, but the process of actuation is completely different. As the name suggests, they utilize light to register a keypress. When you press an optical switch, it cuts off an infrared beam of light present inside the keyboard that triggers the actuation. When released, the beam of light is restored, and the switch is ready for actuation again. Keyboards with optical switches are not anything new, with brands like Razer and Roccat producing optical keyboards for many years now.

Related

What makes a good mechanical keyboard?

Differentiating keyboards can be difficult, but what factors other than features make a mechanical keyboard truly great?

Typing experience, performance, and durability: which switch is right for you?

The feel and speed are all that matters

Knowing how each type of switch works is one thing, but before deciding which keyboard to buy, you also need to know the differences between mechanical, magnetic, and optical switches in terms of the typing experience, performance, and longevity. These differences might be subtle in some areas, but you probably already expect that, and are willing to invest the time and effort needed to understand them deeply before making your choice.

Typing sound and feel

Personally, I consider the typing experience to be the biggest consideration when buying a keyboard. How the keyboard sounds and feels has the biggest impact on how much you will enjoy typing on it. While mechanical switches are renowned for their distinct tactile and aural feedback, there’s no single signature sound or feel that defines them. There are tons of mechanical switches available on the market, each with its own travel distance, actuation force, sound, and feedback. Perhaps the only thing that stays constant with them is the reassuring feedback you get on every keypress.

Magnetic switches generally lack the satisfying feedback accompanying mechanical switches, as they lack any physical contact mechanism within the switches. However, this also makes them feel smoother and less resistant, which some might prefer. In terms of the typing sound, the differences are less pronounced, but magnetic switches are generally more silent. And while most magnetic switches are linear, manufacturers also offer some clicky and tactile options for users who want a more mechanical feel.

Optical switches are closer to magnetic rather than mechanical switches. This is because they too utilize an actuation process that naturally reduces the amount of tactile feedback the user experiences. Optical switches are known to be quite smooth and silent, with many users also describing them as “hollow” or fake when compared to mechanical switches. Similar to Hall effect switches, you’ll mostly find linear options on optical keyboards, but some manufacturers do offer clicky and tactile options.

Gaming performance

Gaming keyboards, of late, have been the biggest focus area for manufacturers when designing mechanical, magnetic, or optical keyboards. This is because the performance differences between these switches are mostly relevant for gamers who are looking to minimize latency and maximize customization.

For the vast majority of gamers, the world of mechanical keyboards has more than enough to offer. Using a switch of your choice, you can easily customize the key travel, actuation force, and latency of your keyboard. Whether it’s remapping keys, recording macros, or disabling keys, almost every keyboard software has the necessary tools. One thing you should note is that mechanical switches will always have what is known as a debounce delay — an approximately 5ms delay due to the time needed for the switch to reset before it’s ready for actuation again.

Magnetic and optical switches come in to sidestep the natural limitations of mechanical switches as far as gaming is concerned. Hall effect switches do not suffer from debounce delay, as they use a completely different actuation method. The biggest draw of most Hall effect keyboards is the adjustable actuation distance, which allows the user to minimize latency at a granular level. Features such as Rapid Trigger and Snap Tap have grown in popularity since they give comparative gamers an edge in situations where milliseconds of differences matter a lot. Whether a Hall effect keyboard will hugely improve your gaming experience is another matter, but it is indisputable that magnetic switches offer features not possible on mechanical keyboards.

When we are talking about latency, nothing comes close to optical switches. The difference might be small, but optical keyboards are technically faster than both mechanical and Hall effect models. Manufacturers often market the lightning-fast response of optical keyboards as their biggest feature.

Another factor that differentiates the Hall effect and optical keyboards from mechanical variants is that they aren’t as friendly with hot-swapping as the latter. Where there are countless mechanical keyboards and switches supporting hot-swapping, doing it on a Hall effect or optical keyboard is relatively difficult due to much fewer choices and support.

Durability and lifespan

The durability aspect might not play a huge role in your decision-making process because either of the three switch types can last for well over a decade, even with intense daily usage. Technically, mechanical switches are the least durable, with the average switch promising 50 to 60 million keystrokes, and topping out at 100 million keystrokes on the best switches.

Magnetic and optical switches, on the other hand, are easily rated for over 100 million keystrokes, which is much more than that of the average mechanical switch. All of these numbers don’t translate into much of a difference, since it’s safe to assume that you won’t be using the same keyboard for 15 years, which happens to be the duration that all of these switches will last for (at a minimum).

Related

I tried Hall effect and I’m sticking with mechanical keyboards for these 3 reasons

If you’re not a high-level gamer, I’m not sure you need a Hall effect keyboard

Pricing and availability: which switch is the most practical?

Old-school or cutting-edge?

You might be able to guess that mechanical switches, being the most common and popular, are the cheapest and most widely available of the three switch types. From established brands to budget vendors, there is no lack of mechanical keyboards on the market, with prices ranging from as low as $50 for a decent budget mechanical keyboard.

Magnetic switches have made a mark in the last few years, and after excellent offerings from Wooting and Razer, almost every other manufacturer, both big and small, has launched its own Hall effect keyboard. On average, you might find Hall effect keyboards priced higher than their mechanical counterparts, especially in the premium segment.

Keyboards with optical switches usually cost more than both mechanical and Hall effect options, even though many of the advantages of optical keyboards are found in their Hall effect counterparts. Fewer manufacturers produce optical switches, and demand is comparatively lower than for the other two keyboard types. You can find optical keyboards from trusted brands such as Razer and Roccat, but expect to pay a premium over mechanical or Hall effect models.

I believe that mechanical switches are mature and feature-packed enough to satisfy almost every gamer or professional looking for a premium typing experience. For gamers who want to minimize latency as much as possible, optical switches are worth the premium. And those who want ultimate control over the switch actuation distance should go for Hall effect switches.

Related

6 reasons you should upgrade to a mechanical keyboard if you haven’t already

Upgrading to a mechanical keyboard offers superior typing, endless features, and limitless customization

It’s a great time for keyboard lovers

Whichever switch you prefer, it’s undoubtedly the best time to jump into mechanical keyboards. Prices have never been lower, the quality of budget models has shot up drastically, and high-end features are becoming more and more accessible. Mechanical, magnetic, or optical — every keyboard type has more than enough to offer gamers, typists, creative professionals, and office users.